PLOT:
Divided in two acts, the musical depicts the life and career of Alexander Hamilton, an orphaned immigrant from the Caribbean island of Nevis. The first act covers Hamilton’s arrival in New York City in 1776, his work as an aide-de-camp to General George Washington during the American Revolution, and how he met and married Eliza Schuyler. The second act covers Hamilton’s postwar work as the first Secretary of the Treasury of the United States, his affair with Maria Reynolds, the death of his son Philip and finally his own death in a duel with Aaron Burr.
REVIEW:
What did I like?
History with a twist. Like most people, I learned the about the founding fathers in History class. I remember getting the basics on Alexander Hamilton and his legacy, but if you were to quiz me on that info, all I could tell you is that he is on the $10 bill. Now, had I seen this back in the day, I’m sure I’d have much more of a recollection of the life and times of Hamilton.I don’t know if that is what Lin-Manuel Miranda had in mind when he put this show together, but I’m sure alot more people are familiar with Hamilton now.
So much talent. This is the original Broadway cast of the show. I think I read that there are one or two roles that are different, but for the most part, these are the actors that brought the show to prominence (and won a Tony). Like most Broadway casts, these actors can sing and dance, as well as act. However, it isn’t a traditional requirement to rap, and yet, here they are spitting rhymes better (and more understandable) than the rapper you hear on the radio today! I was highly impressed watching them do this.
Innovation. If you’ve ever seen a play and/or musical, then you are aware that sets change with the settings. There isn’t one of those in this production. Everything takes place on one stage. There is a platform that spins in the middle of the floor, but that’s mostly for dramatic effect. Aside from being a hip-hop musical featuring an almost entirely minority cast, points must be given to how death is foreshadowed. Not to spoil anything, but there is a character who secretly appears when death is near. I was just told about her right before I sat down to write this and now I’m going to have to go back and see if I can catch her in the act.
What didn’t I like?
Length. This version is just shy of 3 hrs (there is a short intermission, though). For a stage production, that isn’t too bad, but there was talk about making this into a movie. Given all that is going on right now, I don’t know if this was released as a snack and the movie is still coming, or if this is in lieu of a feature length film. At any rate, if this is going to (what will pass for) the big screen in the future, then they need to cut it down by at least 15-30 minutes. The general audience will lose interest with something this long.
Sam Madison. Alexander Hamilton. George Washington. Thomas Jefferson. Aaron Burr. These were great men and are portrayed as such in the film. However, Sam Madison is left out. Wait, let me word that better. He is in the film, but mostly as a conspirator/instigator. If not mentioned by name, you wouldn’t even know he was as important an individual as Sam Madison.
Musical or opera? This is a minor complaint I have with the production, and it has more to do with semantics that anything else. For me, a musical is a play with songs here and there. This production is entirely sung (or rapped) which, by definition, fits more in line with opera. I’m not going to sit here and debate what this is, but I do wonder what this would have been like with a few words spoken, rather than almost entirely sung. Food for thought.
Final verdict:
There has been much hype surrounding Hamilton. Did this production live up to the press? Almost…almost. Don’t get me wrong. This a great production. Most of the songs I enjoyed. There are some truly emotional performances from the cast, as well. I am not buying into the hype simply because I’m not still singing the songs in my head or remembering anything about the main character (Jefferson and Washington were the stand outs for me). That’s my personal bias, though. I do still highly recommend this. If you have Disney+, carve out a 3 hr window and enjoy an evening at the theater with this production.
4 out of 5 stars